Friday, February 28, 2014

Radiometric Dating and the Bill Nye Debate

In the Bill Nye versus young earth creationist Ken Ham debate, Ken gives this response to radiometric dating:

Unfortunately, Bill Nye did not have a satisfactory response to this. Is there one? Yep. Notice from the above video it is apparent that a creationist took the samples and then sent them off to the laboratory for dating (Potassium-Argon for the basalt and radiocarbon for the wood). There is a method of radiometric dating called isochron dating that has a built-in check for most forms of contamination. However, Chris Stassen of TalkOrigins notes that

some dating methods (e.g., K-Ar and carbon-14) do not have a built-in check for contamination, and if there has been contamination these methods will produce a meaningless age. For this reason, the results of such dating methods are not treated with as much confidence.

Bingo: a creationist sent in some stuff for dating when the dating method in question had no built-in check for contamination! Potassium-Argon and radiocarbon dating is not necessarily useless, but one does have to be careful about not sending in contaminated samples, and I am willing to bet the creationists who took the samples did not do that.

1 comment:

  1. If you look at at|have a look at} the entire Pareto graph you’ll find a smoother, longer tail in social. In playing, the participant performs to win and to get some type of a rush. If he wins big, he'll often cash out and would possibly scale back his engagement ranges in the near future. In social gaming, there are many of|there are numerous} more features of social/fun engagement which motivate the participant. The participant desires to compete in the game, to go up in ranges, to beat his friends and to interact with them by sending 1xbet items. Our customer support may be very skilled when it comes to of|in relation to} international online casinos and they are of course specialists in and every little thing our on line casino consists of.